Daphne always cherished the whimsical tale of how she and Peter met—a blustery day, an errant hat, and a love story that seemed destined. But destiny takes a twist when Peter realizes he's truly in love with his childhood best friend, Petra. Stranded in the picturesque town of Waning Bay, Michigan, Daphne is left with no friends, family, or plans—only a dream job as an underpaid children's librarian. In a bold move, she becomes roommates with the one person who understands her predicament: Petra's ex, Miles Nowak. Scruffy and chaotic, with a penchant for heartbreak love ballads, Miles is the complete opposite of buttoned-up Daphne, whose mysterious demeanor has coworkers betting she's either FBI or in witness protection. Their coexistence is awkward until a night of shared sorrows leads to an unexpected friendship and a daring plan. Together, they begin posting misleading photos of their summer adventures, stirring curiosity and maybe a little jealousy. It's all just for show... or is it? As lines blur and hearts waver, Daphne faces a tantalizing possibility. Could she really start a new chapter by falling for her ex-fiancé's new fiancée's ex? Or is she risking heartbreak all over again?