The Outlander Phenomenon: 8 Reasons Behind Its Popularity

Thoughts and words by
October 19, 2023
13
min read
Is Outlander Historically Accurate?

Table of contents

In a world filled with stories, there's one that holds a special place in our hearts—the captivating Outlander series. This literary gem turned television sensation (airing on Starz) has an undeniable appeal that always keeps us coming back for more, much like the enduring love story of Claire and Jamie.

So, what's the magic recipe that makes Outlander so irresistible?

Is it the majestic Scottish Highlands? The allure of time travel? The timeless love story? Or is it perhaps the steamy sex scenes and the magnetic charisma of a certain red-headed Highlander whose charm is as legendary as his knack for finding adventure—and trouble?

So, grab your favorite cozy blanket and a cup of tea and join us on an exploration as we uncover the eight secrets behind the Outlander enigma.

Fair warning for any ill-prepared wanderers: there will be many spoilers ahead.

1. Intriguing Concept: History, Modernity and Time-Travel

At the heart of Outlander's draw lies its masterful integration of time travel.

Diana Gabaldon weaves a complex narrative where Claire Randall, a 20th-century English army nurse, while on her second honeymoon with her husband, Frank, finds herself transported back to 18th-century Scotland through a circle of standing stones called Graigh na Dun.

Source

The plotline's unique blend of magical elements with historical accuracy is brilliantly crafted, immersing readers and viewers in a world where the boundaries of time blur.

Source

In the first season of the series, through Claire’s eyes (Portrayed by Caitriona Balfe), we experience the stark contrast between the British wartime and the wild grandness of the Scottish Highlands. This interplay of eras deepens the narrative, offering us a view into history’s evolution.

The series doesn’t merely use time travel for its novelty; it uses it as a tool to explore human resilience across generations, rendering the storyline profound and relatable for all.

Gabaldon’s intricate storytelling crafts a tale that crosses continents and centuries—from the Jacobite uprisings to the streets of 18th-century Paris, to the American Revolution and beyond. The attention to historical detail doesn’t only paint a pretty backdrop—which, of course, it does, but it also enriches the characters’ experiences and the societal nuances of the story.

Take Jamie Fraser (portrayed in the TV show by Sam Heughan), for instance, a character molded by the social and political landscape of his country and time. His struggles are intertwined with the very fabric of history, showcasing how broader events shape individual fortunes.

This richness of plot ensures that every episode and chapter resonates with authenticity, pulling readers and viewers deeper into the magic of Gabaldon’s world. Through this interplay of history and fiction, the series becomes not just a story but a deeply captivating and immersive experience.

2. Characters You Can Relate To

What makes Outlander truly unforgettable, though, is not the time-traveling aspect of the story, but its main characters —the story’s very soul.

Claire: A strong female protagonist

Claire—or better yet, the Sassenach—is a woman out of time navigating the complexities of love and loyalty across different centuries. Her depth goes far beyond the screen; her fears, hopes, and struggles make her feel like an old friend sharing her story with us, flawed and real.

Source

Jamie: The archetypical hero

And then there is Jamie, a man burdened by history yet always resilient and brave in the face of every adversity. He embodies the complexities of human existence, facing not just external enemies but also private, internal wars.

These characters aren’t immune to life’s harsher realities. They grapple with genuine, heart-wrenching challenges. Their story is not just about political intrigue, sword fights, and picturesque costumes; It’s about love tested by time, morality, and personal demons. The characters’ authenticity is what makes us cry and laugh with them.

3. A Love Story That’s Oh-So-Real

In other words, the love story between Claire and Jamie isn’t just a plotline. Their connection isn’t the stuff we see in fairytales; it's messy, passionate, and deeply human.

Source

They don’t just show us the sunny, blissful side of love; they reveal the stormy, challenging parts too. We see their arguments, their misunderstandings, and all the moments where they hurt each other—not out of malice but out of simple human imperfection. It’s in these struggles that their love shines the brightest exactly because it is not perfect, but it’s genuine.

Source

When they fight, it’s not for drama’s sake; it’s the clash of two strong-willed individuals. When they make up, it’s not a swift resolution; it’s a heartfelt reconciliation born out of understanding and forgiveness. We witness their love evolve—from the first time meeting and the days of newfound passion to the sturdy, enduring bond of a partnership weathered by time and trials.

4. Historical Accuracy

Imagine closing your eyes and being transported to a bygone era, where every detail, from the flickering of the flames in the fireplace to the texture of the clothing and the actual dyes that have been used to color the kilts of the scots, feels real.

That’s the magic of Diana Gabaldon’s writing, where her unwavering commitment to historical accuracy makes the past come alive. And the same kind of magic can be found in the TV series adaptation, too.

Source

The dedication to research is evident in every page—and frame. From the stunningly rugged filming locations to the architecture of the Scottish castles to the trivial matters of daily life, the attention to detail creates a world so vivid and picturesque that it feels authentic.

Source

And it’s not just about the aesthetics. Outlander weaves real historical events into its narrative, integrating them into the characters’ lives. The societal standards, the folklore elements, the Jacobite uprisings, and the battle of Culloden—they are not just background; they are essential parts of the narrative. They make history not a setting but a living, breathing character that deepens the complexity of the plotline.

5. Faithful Adaptation of the Books Series

For fans of Diana Gabaldon’s book series, the television show is evidently worthy of appreciation. The adaptation’s commitment to staying true to Gabaldon’s storytelling is a true testament to its dedication to both existing fandom and the integrity of the story itself.

The Starz series delves into the source material, exploring the small moments, the important lines, and all the decisions that create the essence of the characters. These details are not just easter eggs for loyal bookworms; they are important for maintaining the authenticity of the story.

Take Claire and Jamie, once again, for example. The undeniable chemistry between the actors mirrors the emotional depth of their literary counterparts perfectly. It’s not just about appearances—although, let’s be honest, both actors being absolutely gorgeous doesn’t hurt. But the important thing is that they understand the motives, thoughts, and emotions of the characters and are able to bring them to the surface, even in the smallest moments.

The transition from page to screen is extremely challenging, as we have seen with many disappointing adaptations of beloved novels in the past. The show’s creators, though, seem to understand the importance of the right pacing. The show doesn’t follow the books slavishly, instead, it expands and adapts where needed while staying faithful to the core of the narrative.

6. Multifaceted Themes

Outlander is a love story. But it’s also a time travel adventure, a political intrigue, and a historical deep-dive into important events of the past. Thus, it caters to a very broad set of tastes.

For the history enthusiast, there’s the appeal of stepping into the past and exploring important historical events like the Jacobite uprisings and the American Revolution. Those interested in political aspects of historical fiction get their fair share of the intricacies of power and alliances, and the armchair philosophers get more than enough food for thought in the exploration of fate and destiny through time travel.

Furthermore, Outlander has a social conscience. It doesn’t shy away from presenting weighty universal issues like gender roles and societal expectations.

Claire and Brianna challenge the norms of the past, and their struggles resonate with contemporary issues and discussions of gender equality. The show manages to often make us ponder the parallels between the challenges of the past and those we face today, reflecting our society’s journey towards progress.

Source

7. Thriving Fan Community

The fanbase of the series is a force to be reckoned with, that is for certain. They are not simply content with being passive spectators; they dive headfirst into online discussions, dissecting every episode, speculating about what is to come, and crafting elaborate fan theories. Being a part of the Outlander fan community is a bit like being a part of a neverending book club.

And the best part is, it’s not just the fans discussing matters among themselves. The creator of the show and Dianna Gabaldon herself actively engage with fans, listening to their feedback, their excitement, and their critiques. The creative team values the fans' perspective, recognizing that it's the fans who breathe life into the story.

The actors, too, play a pivotal role in this exchange. They aren't just faces on the screen; they're active participants in the fandom. They share their behind-the-scenes moments, insights into their characters, and their own enthusiasm for the story on social media. This interaction bridges the gap between the fictional world and reality, making the characters they portray feel like real people.

Fan events, whether virtual or in person, become epic gatherings. It's not just about watching; it's about sharing the experience with kindred spirits.

And then there's the fascinating world of fanfiction. Fans take the rich universe of Outlander and expand upon it, creating their own stories, delving into character relationships, and exploring what-if scenarios. These fan-created tales add new dimensions to the Outlander experience, offering fresh perspectives and exciting adventures.

8. Visually Stunning Scenery and Costumes

The rolling hills of Scotland, the bustling streets of 18th-century Paris, and the eerie moors of Craigh na Dun all come alive in stunning detail.

Then there are the costumes and visual elements – a visual feast for the senses. The meticulous craftsmanship is evident in every stitch of fabric, every piece of jewelry, and every carefully chosen prop. Claire's iconic dresses, Jamie's rugged tartan kilts, and the opulent attire of the French aristocracy all transport us to another time.

Source

These visual elements are powerful storytelling tools. The costumes reflect the characters' evolution and their journeys through different periods. The attention to detail adds depth to their personas, making them feel like real-life people from the past.

Source

Want to Know More About Outlander?

In conclusion, Outlander can serve as a reminder that a good story isn't one-dimensional; it's a kaleidoscope of emotions and ideas that can entertain, inspire, and provoke thought all at once. It’s a testament to the power of storytelling to connect with such a diverse audience and leave them all hungry for more.

So, whether you're a long-time fan or a newbie to this captivating universe, we invite you to embrace the Outlander magic.

Dive into the books, rewatch the series, and join fellow fans in discussions—it's a world where time knows no bounds, and adventure awaits in every chapter. Let the magic of the Scottish Highlands and the allure of Claire and Jamie inspire your own adventures.

If you are interested in reading more deep dives into Diana Gabaldon’s worlds, like our review of the first book and detailed comparisons between the books and show, subscribe to the CREW newsletter.

If you are eager to discover more passionate love stories like Claire and Jamie’s, once again, we got you covered. Explore our picks for the best steamy historical novels and other books that remind us of Outlander.

Nina Siscou
Article written by:

Nina Siscou

First and foremost, Nina is a reader; she devours literature with gusto, from classic novels to contemporary poetry to graphic novels and everything in between. She believes that within each story, there's a universe waiting to be explored, and loves exploring with company. She's often found sharing her perspective on characters, plot twists, and literary themes with friends. When her friends get tired of listening to her ranting, she writes blog posts sharing her explorations with the other bookworms of the internet. In recent years she has developed an inexplicable addiction to matcha lattes, but has asked us not to talk about that.