Outlander Book Review: All You Need to Know About the Book

Thoughts and words by
August 11, 2023
14
min read
Is Outlander Historically Accurate?

Table of contents

In the windswept Highlands of Scotland, where mighty mountains stand tall against the sky and age-old mysteries whisper through the misty valleys, a tale of love, adventure, and time awaits every bookworm brave enough to embark on Diana Gabaldon’s masterfully narrated journey. 

Introduction to Outlander: A Novel

(Just a quick heads-up! We're about to reveal some juicy details that could spoil the surprises for those who haven't read the first Outlander book yet. If you're new to Diana Gabaldon’s world and want to avoid spoilers, bookmark this article for later.)

Diana Gabaldon didn’t have the background one would expect when she began writing the first Outlander book (also known as Cross Stitch for the first edition in the UK) quite unexpectedly. 

In the mid-1980s, Gabaldon was writing software reviews and articles for computer publications. Boring, right? But also, she was a professor at Arizona State University with expertise in scientific computation and a background in zoology and ecological behavior. While she had been dreaming of writing fiction since she was a child, she had never pursued her passion seriously. 

So, one day Diana was flipping through television channels when she stumbled upon an episode of Doctor Who. That particular episode featured a young Scottish man in a kilt. The dashing young lad named Jamie McCrimson sparked her imagination and inspired her to write a story set in 18th-century Scotland.

Despite not having any formal training in creative writing, Diana Gabaldon decided to give it a try, just for the fun of it. She approached the writing process as an experiment, wanting to see what it takes to complete an entire novel.

She decided to have ‘an Englishwoman to play off all these kilted Scotsmen.’ Progressively, her female character ‘took over the story and began telling it herself, making smart-ass modern remarks about everything.’

To ensure historical accuracy, Diana did extensive research. She delved into historical references of the time period and visited Scotland to better understand the magnificent landscapes. Her dedication to detail, combined with her love for storytelling and her undeniable talent, resulted in an imaginative narrative that wove together romance, historical fiction, and fantasy.

The first Outlander book was published in 1991.

And then, many more followed.

As of now, the Outlander series consists of nine published novels.

  1. Outlander (1991)
  2. Dragonfly in Amber (1992) and A Fugitive Green (2018)
  3. Voyager (1993)
  4. The Drums of Autumn (1996)
  5. The Fiery Cross (2001)
  6. A Breath of Snow and Ashes (2005)
  7. An Echo in the Bone (2009) and The Space Between (2014)
  8. Written in My Own Heart's Blood (2013) and A Leaf on the Wind of All Hallows (2012)
  9. Go Tell the Bees That I Am Gone (2021)

With the latest book of the series published in November 2021, Gabaldon announced that she is working on the tenth Outlander book, which will, unfortunately, probably be the last.

Gabaldon also published The Exile (An Outlander Graphic Novel) in 2010 as well as the Lord John series, which is a spin-off from the Outlander books. 

You can find a full list of Diana’s published novels here.

Summary

Our story begins in the year 1945, right at the end of World War II. Claire Randal, a former army nurse, and her husband, Frank, are on their second honeymoon in the Scottish Highlands. After being separated for six years, they try to rekindle their relationship and mend the chasm the war has caused between them. If only they could imagine what fate had in store.

Source

One day, while exploring a circle of standing stones called Craigh na Dun (imagine Stone Hedge, only smaller—and more magical), Claire touches a crack in one of the stones and is inexplicably transported, through chaos and time, to the year 1743.

Source

 Claire is disoriented and bewildered, as anyone in her position would be, initially believing she has stumbled upon a film set of some kind. However, she soon encounters a squad of British Redcoats that threaten her safety. By a cruel twist of fate, their captain is Jonathan ‘Black’ Randal, Frank’s six-times-great-grandfather. Despite his outward similarities with Claire’s gentle husband, inwards, Jonathan Randall (Jack Randall) is a dangerous and sadistic man and Claire is bound to be his next victim.

Source

In a stroke of luck, she is rescued (or maybe kidnapped, depending on how you like to look at things) by a group of Scottish clansmen. Among them, she meets the handsome and courageous outlaw warrior, James ‘Jamie’ Fraser. Despite the linguistic and cultural barriers—as well as distrust, remember, Claire is British in a time when the British were not taken too kindly in the Highlands— she uses her medical expertise to tend to the injured warrior and thus gains some trust and respect from the rugged Scots. 

Source

Claire is hastily taken to Castle Leoch of clan MacKenzie, where she has to learn and adapt to the difficult realities of life in the 18th century.

Source

Suspicion surrounds her as she cannot explain her origins convincingly without revealing the truth about her time travelling—and running the very realistic danger of being accused of witchcraft. She uses her medical knowledge to help the inhabitants of the castle, and she slowly gains the trust of Collum MacKenzie, the laird of Leoch, and his younger brother, Dougal.

As Claire tries to find a way to transport back to her own time, she becomes entangled in the politics of the Scottish clans, who are on the brink of rebellion against the British. 

During this time, she grows closer to Jamie, and an undeniable chemistry blossoms between them as she gets to know more about the young warrior’s turbulent past. Despite her loyalty to her husband, Claire begins to develop feelings for Jamie—and we cannot blame her at all; the man is pure charisma.

Claire’s secret and identity eventually draw the suspicions of Captain Jonathan Randal, who accuses her of being a spy and tries to capture her. But in order to protect her, Jamie claims Claire as his wife. Little did she know, that for Captain Randall there was only one person he wanted more than her; Jamie.

Even though their union is a product of necessity, the feelings they harbor for each other are undeniably real. Their forced marriage quickly blossoms into a passionate affair, and Claire has to make an ultimate decision: she can either stay in 1743 Scotland with Jamie or travel back to her own time to Frank. 

When Jamie learns the truth about her identity, he selflessly tries to help her get back to Craigh Na Dun, believing she will be safer and happier in her original timeline. 

However, Claire decides to listen to what her heart dictates and stays with Jamie. How could she not?

Jamie and Claire then return together to Jamie’s ancestral home, Lallybroch, where she meets his beloved sister and his childhood best friend. 

As Jamie’s past is revealed, Captain Randall's obsession with him becomes more clear. And when Jamie gets captured and imprisoned for the crime he is wrongfully accused of, Claire would stop at nothing to save him. And so, she embarks on a perilous adventure trying to save his life.

In a  gripping, heart-pounding climax of the story, Claire and Jamie face the ultimate test. The choices they make and the sacrifices they endure will change the course of their lives forever.

Source

The Main Outlander Characters

Claire Beauchamp Randall Fraser - the "Sassenach" portrayed by Catriona Balfe Caitríona Balfe

Source

Claire is an English nurse, a botany enthusiast, and…time traveler. 

From the very beginning of her introduction, it is evident to the reader that Claire is a woman ahead of her time in 1945 and a complete out-of-place miracle by 1743 standards. Strongminded and fiercely independent, opinionated, and compassionate, Claire is a wonderful lead and narrator in the first book.

Born on October 1918 to Julia and Henry Beauchamp, Claire’s life took a tragic turn when her parents died in a car accident. Claire was left in the care of her uncle, an archeologist, and historian named Quentin Lambert Beauchamp. 

Although he attempted to enroll her in a boarding school, Claire’s strong-headed nature prevailed and stopped him. She chose to live a nomadic life alongside him, traveling in various places of the world—a fact that heavily influences her character. 

During her nomadic existence, Claire met Frank Randall, a historian who helped her uncle’s research. They fell in love and married soonly after. Their marriage was a happy one, based on equal admiration and respect. However, the Second World War forced them to devote themselves to the war effort. Claire became a combat nurse, and Frank served as an MI6 officer.

After Claire is transported back to 1743, her character truly starts to shine through the pages. She is resilient, adaptive, and stubborn. 

She has a natural aversion to taking orders and a quick-witted mouth that often gets her in trouble. She is a very competent healer that can maintain a reassuring composure during stressful situations—and believe us, there are plenty. 

As the story progresses and she slowly falls in love with Jamie, the affectionate and passionate side of her character unravels. Through their loving relationship and the perilous journey they are forced to embark on, she discovers the depths of her resilience and selflessness. 

Claire is a deep, exquisitely crafted character, a captivating narrator that at times feels like an older friend or relative that recounts to us her magnificent life story. 

James Alexander Malcolm MacKenzie Fraser (Jamie Fraser) - the ‘Fan favorite.’

Portrayed by Sam Heughan

Source

James Fraser is a 23-year-old Scottish soldier and landowner. 

A warrior at heart (and body), Jamie’s combat skills are unmatched. He demonstrates skill with various weapons, and he is a formidable force against any foe. 

However, it is his immense sense of compassion that sets him apart from traditional warrior figures. Jamie values life, and he is reluctant to take one unless it is absolutely necessary. 

His upbringing has instilled in him a deep-rooted sense of honor and loyalty. He is a man of integrity, unyielding in his principles, and always ready to sacrifice himself for those he loves.

Jamie’s interactions with other characters reflect his ability to make quick friendships and inspire loyalty. He is a natural leader. 

Jamie's emotional depth and capacity for love make him a unique and truly endearing character. His love for Claire is fierce and all-consuming. Despite the many challenges thrown in their paths, Jamie remains devoted to her, showing unwavering understanding and support. 

Despite his stoic and, at times, humorous demeanor, Jamie harbors a deep well of emotions, and his vulnerability comes through when confronted with loss, pain, or memories of his past.  

He grapples with guilt and inner conflict, haunted by the choices he had to make in order to protect his loved ones.

Through the storyline, Jamie’s character constantly evolves, and changes through experiences that test his resilience and reshape his identity. 

Reception and Popularity

The debut novel of Diana Gabaldon’s series burst into the literary scene in 1991, capturing the hearts of bookworms all around the world.

The story’s unique premise, transporting a 20th-century heroine back to 18th-century Scotland, proved to have an irresistible appeal for readers seeking an imaginative, new narrative. 

Source

The seamless interweaving of fascinating historical events with a gripping love story sparked interest among a diverse audience, from history enthusiasts to devoted romantics.

Source

Gabaldon’s meticulous research and attention to detail brought the Highlands to life through the pages, introducing readers to the breathtakingly beautiful landscapes of Scotland and immersing them in the forgotten traditions and folklore of the 18th century. 

Source

The masterfully crafted chemistry between Claire and Jamie also struck a chord with readers from the very beginning. Their extraordinary love, blossoming despite all odds amidst danger and political unrest, captivated the hearts of countless readers, thus making them one of literature’s most cherished couples. 

As Outlander gained popularity, its acclaim spread from mouth-to-mouth recommendations and enthusiastic reviews. 

The romance novel's suspenseful plot and passionate romance kept the fans eagerly anticipating each next installment of the series. 

The first book's success inspired a multitude of spin-offs, adaptations, fanfictions (and countless vacation trips to the Highlands), solidifying its place as a cultural sensation. 

Source

Outside the pages, the Outlander book series was adapted into a successful TV series by Starz that further expanded its reach to an even bigger audience. 

Decades after its first publication, Outlander remains a vastly influential novel (as proven by you, reading this very blog post at this very moment). 

It continues to resonate with readers, and by now, we can be certain that Claire’s and Jamie's timeless love story will be cherished for generations to come. 

Final Verdict: Pros and Cons of Outlander

Diana Gabaldon weaves a mesmerizing tapestry of love, loyalty, and the struggle to survive in a time of turmoil. With its compelling characters and immersive narrative, Outlander captivates readers in an exploration of human emotions, moral dilemmas, and the enduring power of love that transcends both time and space.

However, we here at Cr3w Stories like to be thorough and just. So we have comprised a list of all the things we enjoyed in the first novel of the series and the things we thought that maybe…wouldn’t be for everyone…

Pros

  • Captivating Premise. The novel’s blend of historical fiction, historical romance, and time travel sets it apart from conventional genres.
  • Rich Historical Detail. Gabaldon’s incorporation of real historical events and settings adds depth and realism to the storyline, opening a window for readers straight into the 18th century.
  • Well-developed Characters. The characters are complex and compelling individuals with realistic flaws, strengths, and emotional depth that make them relatable and endearing.
  • Gripping Plot. The storyline of the novel is full of suspense and intrigue.
  • Compelling prose. Diana Gabaldon’s evocative writing and immersive description create a vivid reading experience that excites the imagination.

(Potential) Cons

  • Slow pacing. Some readers may find the story’s progression slow, particularly during the beginning. A bit of patience might be required before the plot really gains its momentum.
  • Triggering Content. Outlander contains many scenes of violence, explicit content, and other adult themes and tropes that may not be suitable for all readers. The story includes descriptions of sensitive and traumatic subjects that could be triggering.
  • Complex Language. The historical novel features Scottish dialect and historical terminology, which might be challenging to understand and follow at times.
  • Lengthy and Complex. The novel is quite lengthy and involves intricate plotlines and many characters, something that may be overwhelming at times.

Outlander stole our heart, and rightfully so! If you are suffering from Outlander withdrawal, you can check out our article about what to read after Outlander.

And since we love Historical Fiction just as much as you do, you can find out more in our blog.

Source

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the Outlander book about?

The Outlander book is an imaginative tale set in two distinct time periods. The storyline follows Claire, a combat nurse from post-Second world war England, as she travels back in time to 18th-century Scotland. There she meets and falls in love with an outlaw warrior named Jamie Frazer. Their story explores themes of love, loyalty, morality, and survival in times of turmoil.

What age is the Outlander book appropriate for?

We would recommend the Outlander series to readers 18 years old and older as it contains many violent and explicit scenes as well as adult themes. 

For all the younger bookworms, we advise patience and a rewatch of Doctor Who. Time will fly before you know it!

Are Outlander books spicy?

The Outlander series explores in detail the passionate relationship between Claire and Jamie. There are many steamy scenes in the story. 

Are the Outlander books worth reading?

A big unanimous YES on our part! …………….

Nina Siscou
Article written by:

Nina Siscou

First and foremost, Nina is a reader; she devours literature with gusto, from classic novels to contemporary poetry to graphic novels and everything in between. She believes that within each story, there's a universe waiting to be explored, and loves exploring with company. She's often found sharing her perspective on characters, plot twists, and literary themes with friends. When her friends get tired of listening to her ranting, she writes blog posts sharing her explorations with the other bookworms of the internet. In recent years she has developed an inexplicable addiction to matcha lattes, but has asked us not to talk about that.