Donna Tartt’s “The Secret History” is an American novel that delves deep in the allure of intellectualism and the dark, often dangerous, path of obsession.
Set against the eerie backdrop of a prestigious Vermont college, the story centers on a friend group of classics students whose academic pursuits and fascination—or, let’s be real, obsession—with the ancient Greek culture lead them through a labyrinth of moral ambiguity, betrayal, and even murder.
Often hailed as the mother of dark academia, “The Secret History” has achieved a modern classic status and significant critical acclaim since its publication thirty years ago. Its intricate plot and richly developed characters have captivated readers worldwide, starting waves of both academic and aesthetic fascination. On BookTok, the book has experienced a resurgence in popularity, with fans eagerly discussing its themes, dissecting its characters, and sharing their interpretations of its many complex moral dilemmas.
So, how could we not be a part of the conversation?
In this article, we will dive deep into the intricate lives of The Secret History’s characters, trying to unravel the layers of these enigmatic individuals, and gain insight into the fragility of innocence and the harrowing journey from idealism to corruption.
Buckle up, bookworms, and beware of spoilers; there are lots to come!
The characters of the novel are the heartbeat of the narrative, each one meticulously crafted to embody the themes and tensions that drive the story to its conclusion.
Richard Papen serves as both the central character and the (frankly unreliable) narrator of the story. His journey from a complete outsider to a complicit member of the elite group of college students forms the backbone of the novel. He narrates the events that led to the murder of one of his “friends” years after the happening. Richard’s story explores the human desire for belonging, the seductive allure of beauty and intellect, and the moral compromises one makes in his quest for acceptance.
Richard arrives at Hampden College in New England from Plano, California, desperate to escape the stifling environment of his parents’ home and the pre-med classes he had been taking, both of which he describes with disdain. Hampden represents a new beginning for him, a place where he can redefine himself. His background is humble, so he feels a deep sense of alienation from his surroundings when he first arrives. His outsider status makes him particularly susceptible to the allure of the elite group of classic students he encounters. Mentored by Julian Morrow but led by the enigmatic Henry Winter, this group represents everything Richard yearns for: sophistication, exclusivity, and intellectual depth. Richard’s initial attraction to the exclusive class is rooted in his admiration for their world of classical beauty and intellectual rigor. He sees their circle as an escape from the banality of his previous life. To fit in with the wealthy and enigmatic Greek students, Richard spends his first semester pretending to be something he’s not. His fabricated tales and polished mannerisms are part of a carefully constructed facade to gain acceptance. His longing to belong to this exclusive group is palpable, and it drives much of his actions throughout the novel.
As Richard slowly becomes more integrated into the Greek class, he is increasingly drawn to their unconventional lifestyle and the mysterious knowledge they pursue under Julian’s guidance. He is seduced by the idea of living a life steeped in beauty and intellectualism, where the ordinary rules of society simply do not apply. Richard’s infatuation with Camilla and his admiration for Henry, who embodies the ideal of the intellectual aristocrat, are particularly intense. Henry’s detached and philosophical musings on beauty and morality captivate Richard, further drawing him into their world.
However, Richard is never just a character within the group; he is also a reflection of the other members and their flaws. His desire for acceptance mirrors the others’ insecurities and need for validation. Henry’s cold intellectualism, Bunny’s carefree yet manipulative nature, the twins’ intertwined lives, and Francis’s flamboyant escapism are all aspects of Richard’s own psyche, magnified and distorted. Richard’s transformation and moral descent highlight the shared weaknesses within the group, illustrating how echo chambers can magnify individual flaws and lead to mutual downfalls.
The turning point in Richard’s journey occurs during his second semester, when he discovers the dark secret the group has been hiding: during a Bacchanal, they accidentally killed someone. The group’s fear of being caught is exacerbated by Bunny, who has found out about the murder and is blackmailing them. This revelation thrusts Richard into a moral dilemma. Despite his initial shock, he chooses to stand by his friends, a decision that leads him down a path of no return. The plot to murder Bunny is executed with chilling precision. The group, including Richard, lures Bunny to a remote location and pushes him off a cliff. This act of violence marks the beginning of Richard’s psychological unraveling. The ensuing search for Bunny’s body and the constant fear of being discovered weigh heavily on him. Richard’s attempts to cope through sex and drugs are completely futile; his nights are plagued by nightmarish images of Bunny’s death, and his days are marked by an overwhelming sense of guilt and paranoia.
Richard’s journey is a poignant exploration of the fragility of innocence and the seductive power of beauty and intellect. Ultimately, Richard and his fellow Greek students get away with the murder, but the victory is hollow. Richard is left in a state of perpetual misery, his soul scarred by the events he cannot escape. His story is a powerful reminder of the human tendency to idealize what we do not have, and the painful realization that comes when those ideals crumble.
From the moment Richard meets him, Henry exudes an aura of sophistication and intelligence that is almost otherworldly. His character is defined by his profound knowledge of classical studies. But Henry’s academic excellence is not just a pursuit of knowledge but a true lifestyle, a way to elevate himself above the mundane concerns of ordinary life and into something greater. He is a figure of immense intellectual prowess, whose admiration for his professor Julian borders on reverence. Julian’s influence is evident in Henry’s philosophical musings and his complete detachment from current events.
Henry’s desire to immerse himself in the past is much more than mere escapism—it is an obsession that drives him to recreate the Dionysian madness of ancient rituals. His success accidentally leads to a frenzied state and the murder of an innocent man. This event sets the stage for the group’s subsequent actions and Henry’s increasingly dominant role in their moral unraveling. His cold, calculated approach to handling the aftermath, particularly his plan to murder Bunny Corcoran to silence him, reveals the depths of his detachment and his capacity for manipulation.
Richard initially views Henry with admiration, but over time, he becomes increasingly aware of Henry’s manipulative nature. Henry’s calm and collected demeanor throughout the planning and execution of Bunny’s murder is chilling. He remains detached and apathetic even during Bunny’s funeral when faced with the results of his actions. Richard later reflects on how much he himself was manipulated by Henry adding a layer of complexity to Henry’s character. Henry’s admission to Richard that he felt emotionally dead inside until he killed someone underscores his profound psychological maladjustment.
Henry’s relationships within the group are intricate and fraught with tension. His closeness with Camilla, which evolves into an implied romantic relationship, creates a rift with her twin brother, Charles. Charles’s fear that Henry is planning to kill him adds a layer of suspense and highlights the disintegration of trust within the group. Henry’s ability to maintain control and influence over the group, despite these tensions, speaks to his charismatic dominance.
The climax of Henry’s story is marked by his ultimate sacrifice—much like the tragic ancient heroes he so much admires. Faced with the threat of the group’s downfall, Henry chooses to end his life, thus sparing Richard, Camilla, Charles, and Francis from prison. This act of self-destruction is both a final assertion of control and a tragic culmination of his journey. After his death, Henry’s presence lingers in Richard’s dreams, symbolizing the inescapable impact of his actions and the lasting effect of their shared experiences.
Henry Winter is a character whose brilliance and darkness are inextricably linked. His intellectual allure, moral ambiguity, and ultimate self-destruction make him a compelling figure whose influence extends beyond his life. Henry Winter remains one of the most unforgettable characters in modern literature, a figure whose tragic wisdom continues to captivate and disturb long after the novel’s final pages.
Edmund “Bunny” Corcoran is a pivotal character whose charm and seemingly carefree demeanor originally mask a deeper, more manipulative nature. Bunny is both the catalyst for the story’s darkest moments and a complex figure whose flaws and vulnerabilities are key to understanding Tartt’s exploration of morality, loyalty, and betrayal.
Bunny hails from an old-money family steeped in tradition and privilege. Despite his family’s declining financial status, Bunny carries himself with the entitlement of someone who has always had access to the best that life can offer. His upbringing in this privileged yet financially strained environment shapes much of his behavior and attitudes. The pressure to maintain appearances and the fear of losing his social standing drive many of his actions throughout the story.
In the innocent beginning, Bunny comes across as the quintessential good-natured, affable friend. He is the only one within the group of students that maintains relationships with others, even having a girlfriend, Marion. Bunny’s sociable nature is a critical aspect of his character; it allows him to navigate social circles with ease and ingratiate himself with others, despite his many flaws. His jovial personality and tendency to lighten the mood provide a contrast to the more somber and serious nature of his peers— namely, Henry. Beneath Bunny’s charm, however, lies a manipulative and self-serving nature. He often exploits his friends’ generosity, taking advantage of their wealth without any intention of reciprocating. His sense of entitlement and complete lack of self-awareness make him a burdensome presence in the group. His manipulative tendencies are particularly evident in his relationship with Francis and Henry. He is a bully to Francis, viewing him as inferior due to his sexuality, while he both admires and resents Henry. He uses his charm to get what he wants but is also capable of cruelty, especially when he feels threatened or insecure.
Bunny’s role as the catalyst for the central conflict cannot be understated. His discovery of the group’s secret—the ritual that inadvertently led to the murder of the local farmer—sets off a chain reaction that propels the story toward its dark climax. Bunny’s knowledge of the secret becomes a weapon he wields to control and manipulate the group, demanding their continued support and threatening to expose them if his demands are not met. His increasingly erratic behavior and veiled threats “force” the group into a corner, leading them to an irreversible decision: Bunny must be eliminated to protect their secret and their futures.
Bunny’s character serves as a mirror reflecting the hypocrisy and moral failings of the group. While they view him as a burden and a threat, their decision to murder him reveals their own capacity for cruelty and moral corruption. Bunny’s insistence on maintaining appearances and his eventual exposure of the group’s secret force them to confront their own duplicity and the fragile nature of their intellectual and moral superiority.
While Bunny’s actions make him a problematic and often antagonistic figure, Tartt also imbues him with a degree of vulnerability and complexity. His behavior is partly driven by his insecurities and the need for validation from his peers. This complexity makes Bunny a more sympathetic character, despite his flaws, and highlights the theme of human vulnerability that runs throughout the novel.
As one of Julian Morrow’s students and Richard’s close friends, Francis brings a unique blend of french sophistication, hedonism, and vulnerability to the group of Greek students. His journey through the novel is marked by his struggle with identity, the burden of secrecy, and the ultimate cost of societal expectations.
Francis comes from an affluent background, much like Henry, but he is markedly different in his approach to his wealth. He tends to downplay his privileged upbringing, choosing instead to focus on the intellectual and hedonistic pursuits that define his life at Hampden College. His country house becomes a haven for the Greek students, a place where they can indulge in their scholarly discussions and increasingly dangerous escapades away from the prying eyes of the college and society.
Francis’s involvement in Bunny’s murder is a testament to his loyalty to the group and his susceptibility to peer pressure. Like Richard, he struggles with the moral implications of their actions. In the aftermath, Francis copes through a haze of sex and drugs, a method of escapism that only partially succeeds in numbing his guilt. Despite these coping mechanisms, Francis manages to maintain a semblance of composure, a facade that belies the turmoil within.
In the second half of the novel, Francis becomes a crucial repository of information. His candid revelations to Richard about the incestuous relationship between Charles and Camilla, as well as his own sexual encounters with Charles, shed light on the complex and often hidden dynamics within the group. These disclosures add to the already intricate web of relationships, highlighting Francis’s role as both an insider and an observer.
Francis’s struggle with his identity is a poignant aspect of his character. His homosexuality, a fact he does not openly discuss, becomes a significant source of conflict, especially when his grandfather threatens to disown him unless he marries a woman. This ultimatum pushes Francis to the edge, leading to a suicide attempt that he ultimately survives. The prospect of a loveless marriage looms over him, a grim reminder of the societal expectations and personal sacrifices that continue to plague him even after the events at Hampden.
Francis Abernathy’s character is a study in contrasts: the outwardly confident, wealthy aesthete who harbors deep insecurities and a longing for acceptance. His flamboyant demeanor masks a vulnerability that resonates with anyone who has felt the pressure to conform to societal norms while grappling with their true self. Francis’s story is a tragic one, marked by the highs of intellectual and sensual indulgence and the lows of existential despair.
Charles and Camilla are Richard’s favorite members of the Greek student group during his first semester at Hampden College. Their close bond and enigmatic charm draw Richard in, offering him a sense of belonging that he desperately craves. Charles, with his easygoing nature and seemingly carefree attitude, becomes a central figure in Richard’s new life. However, beneath the surface, Charles is grappling with deep-seated issues that will eventually come to light.
Bunny’s murder and its aftermath have a profound impact on Charles, who finds himself regularly called in for questioning by the authorities. This process, combined with the weight of his guilt, takes a severe toll on him. Charles struggles to maintain a facade of calm and is visibly distressed by the situation. As the pressure mounts, Charles turns to alcohol to cope with his anxiety and guilt. His heavy drinking becomes a destructive force, worsening his already fragile mental state. The revelation of his incestuous relationship with Camilla makes his character ever more complex. This relationship, which is both taboo and deeply unsettling, underscores the dysfunction and moral decay within the group.
Camilla’s eventual confession to Richard about Charles’s abusive behavior shatters any remaining illusions of their idyllic sibling bond. She reveals that she moved out of their shared apartment due to Charles’s regular abuse, seeking refuge in a place Henry provided for her. This revelation not only exposes the toxic dynamics within their relationship but also highlights Charles’s increasing paranoia.
Charles’s paranoia reaches a fever pitch as he becomes convinced that Henry is out to get him, too. His fear and rage culminate in a desperate and violent confrontation at Francis’s country house, where he overhears a phone conversation between Richard and Henry. Misinterpreting their conversation, Charles believes that the group is plotting to murder him. He flees, only to return later armed with a gun, intent on killing Henry.
The climactic moment occurs when Charles inadvertently shoots Richard instead of Henry. This act of violence, born out of paranoia and desperation, shows Charles’s complete psychological breakdown. It is a stark reminder of how far he has fallen from the charming, charismatic figure he once was.
Following Henry’s death, the group disintegrates, and Charles’s life spirals further out of control. He disappears from the lives of his former friends, ultimately losing contact with everyone except for sporadic updates from Camilla. According to her, Charles ends up in Texas and he continues to struggle with alcoholism.
Camilla Macauley is a character of elegant beauty and quiet strength. As the twin sister of Charles and the only female among Julian’s prized students, Camilla’s presence is both a calming influence and a source of intrigue, particularly for Richard, who is infatuated with her throughout the novel. Her story is a nuanced exploration of resilience, complex relationships, and silent suffering.
Richard’s infatuation with Camilla is a recurring theme in the novel. Despite his feelings, Richard and Camilla never enter into a romantic relationship, largely due to the intricate and often troubling dynamics that define their circle. Camilla’s allure lies not just in her physical appearance, but in her calm and composed nature amidst the chaos that surrounds them.
Camilla, like the other Greek students, is complicit in Bunny’s murder. However, unlike some of her peers who unravel under the weight of their guilt, Camilla maintains a remarkable composure. Her ability to handle the aftermath of the murder sets her apart, showcasing th resilience of her character. Yet, this stoicism also hints at a deeper, more complex internal struggle that she manages to keep hidden from those around her.
The relationship between Camilla and Charles is central to her narrative. As Charles succumbs to alcoholism and becomes increasingly volatile, the strain on Camilla intensifies. His physical abuse forces her to leave their shared apartment and seek refuge in a room provided by Henry. This move marks a significant shift in Camilla’s life, as she attempts to distance herself from the toxic dynamics of her brother’s breakdown.
One of the most shocking revelations in the novel is the incestuous relationship between Camilla and Charles. This taboo relationship adds a layer of complexity to Camilla’s character, delving into the depth of her entanglement in the group’s dysfunction. Charles’s jealousy and paranoia, particularly his suspicion that Camilla and Henry are involved, exacerbate the already tense situation, driving him further into madness.
Towards the end of the novel, after Henry’s death and the disintegration of the group, Camilla remains a figure of quiet strength. Her final encounter with Richard, following Francis’s suicide attempt, is a moment that perfectly portrays her complexity. Richard’s marriage proposal, driven by his longstanding affection for her, is met with a refusal. Camilla’s reason—that she still loves Henry—reveals the depth of her emotional scars and her enduring attachment to Henry, despite the chaos and tragedy that defined their relationship.
In “The Secret History,” Charles and Camilla Macaulay are twins with an exceptionally close and complex relationship. Their bond is characterized by deep mutual dependence and an almost exclusive intimacy, with incestuous undertones. Charles is possessive and jealous, particularly of Camilla’s interactions with other group members like Henry. As the novel progresses and their shared guilt and trauma intensify, their relationship becomes strained, with Charles descending into alcoholism and erratic behavior, while Camilla tries to maintain stability. Their relationship adds to the tension and highlights the themes of blurred moral and social boundaries.
Richard is quietly infatuated with Camilla, admiring her beauty, grace, and intellect. Camilla values Richard’s sensitivity and steadiness amid the group’s turmoil. However, their bond is complicated by the group’s dark secrets and Richard’s awareness of Camilla’s close, often tense relationship with her twin brother, Charles. As the group’s collective guilt and paranoia grow, the strain on their relationship intensifies, yet an underlying bond of shared experience and understanding persists.
Julian Morrow serves as the classics professor whose teachings and influence bind the main characters together. He mentors the group through an intensive study of ancient Greek culture and philosophy, fostering a sense of intellectual elitism and moral ambiguity. Julian’s lack of ethical guidance and his encouragement to seek beauty and truth in unconventional ways indirectly contribute to the group’s descent into criminal behavior. While he is not directly involved in their dark deeds, his absence during their moral crises highlights his detachment from the consequences of his teachings, making him a pivotal yet morally ambiguous figure in the novel.
Bunny’s girlfriend, Marion, plays a subtle yet crucial role in the story by humanizing Bunny and adding the complexity of consequence. Through Marion, readers glimpse Bunny’s more vulnerable side, contrasting with his domineering behavior within the group. Her concern for Bunny amplifies the group’s anxiety as they plan his murder, fearing her potential to notice his distress. Marion’s grief and confusion after Bunny’s death underscore the broader real-world impact of the group’s actions, highlighting the ripple effect of their crime beyond their insular circle and adding depth to the story’s moral and emotional complexities.
Richard’s friend Judy plays a minor yet crucial role in showcasing the contrast between the elite world of the Greek students and the more typical college experience. Judy is a fellow student at Hampden College, known for her bohemian lifestyle and casual, down-to-earth demeanor. Her interactions with Richard provide a necessary grounding element, reminding him of the normalcy outside the intense and often toxic environment of the Greek students.
Judy’s presence serves as a counterbalance to the high-stakes drama and intellectual pretension of Richard’s new circle. She represents the carefree side of college life, offering Richard a glimpse into what his life might have been like if he had not become entangled with Henry and the others.
Cloke Rayburn is Bunny’s friend from high school and plays an intriguing role in the story. Known for his drug use and dealing, Cloke becomes anxiously concerned when Bunny goes missing, fearing that his own illicit activities might come to light. His anxiety is evident in his suspiciously specific denial during an interview, where he assures, “Bunny is a real straight guy—definitely not mixed up in drugs or anything like that.”
Donna Tartt’s novel is a gripping and haunting read that sticks with you long after you’ve finished it. Its rich plot and layered characters make it a perfect choice for a book club. It’s got everything you need for a great discussion: intrigue, drama, and enough intellectual pretension to make you feel like you’re back in college—minus the student loans and questionable cafeteria food. So, grab a glass of wine (or two), gather your friends, and dive into the twisted world of “The Secret History.” Trust me, you’ll have plenty to talk about!
For more book deep dives and content around your favorite reads, subscribe to the crewfiction newsletter!
Yes, the novel features Francis Abernathy, who is a gay man, and his sexuality plays a significant role in the story. Francis’s relationships and his struggle with his identity are important aspects of his character. Additionally, there are subtle implications and complex dynamics regarding other characters’ sexualities, adding depth to the narrative and exploring themes of identity and societal expectations.
The characters in Donna Tartt's “The Secret History” are believed to be inspired by Tartt’s real life experiences and acquaintances during her time at Bennington College. The characters exhibit traits and dynamics reminiscent of the close-knit, elite academic circles found in such environments. Henry Winter, for example, embodies the archetype of the intellectual prodigy, while Richard Papen represents the outsider drawn into an alluring yet morally ambiguous world. Other characters, like Bunny Corcoran and the flamboyant Francis Abernathy, also reflect the eclectic, intense personalities that might be found in a secluded, academically rigorous setting.
In “The Secret History,” the antagonist is not a single character but rather a combination of internal and external forces. While Henry’s manipulative and morally detached actions drive much of the plot’s conflict, making him a central antagonist figure, the true antagonistic force in the novel is the collective moral corruption and intellectual hubris of the group. This leads to their downfall, representing the destructive power of elitism, guilt, and the darker aspects of human nature. These elements create an atmosphere where the characters’ own actions and psychological turmoil serve as the primary antagonistic force, rather than any one individual.
First and foremost, Nina is a reader; she devours literature with gusto, from classic novels to contemporary poetry to graphic novels and everything in between. She believes that within each story, there's a universe waiting to be explored, and loves exploring with company. She's often found sharing her perspective on characters, plot twists, and literary themes with friends. When her friends get tired of listening to her ranting, she writes blog posts sharing her explorations with the other bookworms of the internet. In recent years she has developed an inexplicable addiction to matcha lattes, but has asked us not to talk about that.
