Daisy Jones & The Six: A Comprehensive Book Review

Thoughts and words by
September 19, 2024
13
min read
Is Outlander Historically Accurate?

Table of contents

You know those books that just won’t let go of you? 

Daisy Jones & The Six

Well, Daisy Jones and The Six by Taylor Jenkins Reid is definitely one of them. Set in the chaotic, glam-soaked 1970s American rock scene, this book narrates the rise and fall of a fictional band so convincingly, you’ll catch yourself googling their greatest hits… only to remember they don’t actually exist. 

If you are on BookTok, chances are you have seen this one all over your feed. It’s a favorite for a reason, and now it’s got a miniseries adaptation on Prime Video that fans are devouring with no hesitation—yes, with some differences, but that’s a whole other discussion that you can find in our article comparing the book with the TV show. Whether you read it before or jumped in because of the series, it’s the kind of story that makes you feel like you’re right there, in the heart of the '70s, surrounded by rock ‘n’ roll, love triangles, and all kinds of beautiful, messy drama.

The book’s unique format—an oral history—reads like a raw, behind-the-scenes music documentary. Think “Behind the Music,” but with more drugs, some fiery band arguments, and a ton of emotional tension. But, while it’s packed with rock-star moments, at its core, this is a story about relationships—love, addiction, ambition, and the sacrifices people make for their art. It’s glamorous, tragic, and totally addictive. If you want to reap the benefits of listening to music while reading, blasting the “Aurora” album while delving into the book is your best shot. 

Spoiler Warning: If you haven’t read Daisy Jones & The Six yet, consider this your official warning—there will be spoilers ahead for both book and show.

A Brief Summary

Daisy Jones & The Six is a fictional oral history of the rise—and inevitable fall—of a rock band in the late 1970s, set against the backdrop of the Los Angeles music scene. Loosely based on Fleetwood Mac and all the gossip and tension surrounding Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham, the novel transports us into the chaotic, glamorous world of sex, drugs, and rock and roll.

At the center of the story are two complicated characters: Daisy Jones (Riley Keough for the TV Show), a magnetic and free-spirited singer-songwriter with raw, undeniable talent, and Billy Dunne (Sam Claflin), the driven and troubled lead singer of The Six, an almost famous rock band from Pittsburgh. Billy, wrestling with his past struggles with addiction, is determined to stay faithful to his wife, Camila, while Daisy seems to live life on the edge, fueled by her own reckless choices and an increasing reliance on drugs. Their lives and careers collide when Daisy joins the band to record a duet with Billy (Honeycomb/ Look At Us Now), a collaboration that becomes a major hit. Together, Daisy’s wild, untamed energy and Billy’s intense focus make them an electrifying duo on stage, but offstage, their relationship is strained, full of creative tension, personal demons, and unresolved emotions.

The novel doesn’t just focus on Daisy and Billy, though; it delves into the lives of the other members of The Six, each with their own stories and struggles. There’s Billy’s younger brother, Graham (Will Harrison), the band’s loyal lead guitarist, who quietly pines for Karen Sirko (Suki Waterhouse), the band’s no-nonsense keyboardist. Karen is determined to keep her focus on the music and her career, avoiding the pitfalls of romance—though she’s secretly involved with Graham. Then there’s Eddie (Josh Whitehouse), the guitarist who grows increasingly resentful of Billy’s leadership, feeling overshadowed and underappreciated. Warren (Sebastian Chacon), the band’s laid-back drummer, seems to coast through the drama, enjoying the rock-star lifestyle without getting too caught up in the tension around him. Pete, Eddie’s brother and the band’s bassist, chooses to leave the band, opting for a quieter life away from the excess and chaos of fame.

As they skyrocket to fame, the band members’ lives become more and more entangled. The chemistry between Daisy and Billy drives their performances but also fuels their conflict, as Billy struggles to stay sober and loyal to Camila while Daisy spirals deeper into addiction and self-destruction. The band’s internal dynamics become more strained as egos clash, and romantic tensions simmer beneath the surface. Billy and Daisy’s complicated connection sits at the heart of the band’s turmoil—creative partners on stage, but offstage, they’re constantly at odds, having their own battles.

Ultimately, Daisy Jones & The Six is more than just a story about rock 'n' roll. It’s about the complicated nature of relationships, the sacrifices people make in pursuit of their art, and the cost of fame. Through the band’s highs and lows, readers get a front-row seat to the personal heartbreak, betrayals, and intense passions that come with life in the spotlight.

Reception and Popularity: From Book Club Favorite to Pop Culture Phenomenon

Since its release, Daisy Jones & The Six has exploded in popularity, quickly becoming one of those “everyone’s talking about it” books. Whether it’s the nostalgic vibe of the 1970s rock ‘n’ roll scene, the gripping character dynamics, or Taylor Jenkins Reid’s unique storytelling, something in this novel sticks with you. It’s the kind of book that you recommend to your friends and then spend hours dissecting. The truth is, Daisy Jones & The Six doesn’t just invite you in—it grabs you by the hand and throws you straight into the chaos and thrill of a rock band on the rise.

A big part of its charm comes from the way it’s told. Reid’s decision to structure the novel like a series of interviews makes you feel like you’re watching an old VH1 documentary, peeling back the layers of these characters through their own words. It’s intimate, it’s raw, and it’s loaded with drama. Readers can’t get enough of the way every character’s version of events slightly clashes, leaving you wondering who’s really telling the truth. That twisty, tangled “he said, she said” vibe is what makes the book such a page-turner.

On top of that, Daisy Jones & The Six found a loving home on BookTok. Fans were quick to latch onto the electric tension between Daisy and Billy, the heartbreak, the music, and the beautifully broken characters. Before you knew it, everyone was posting their favorite quotes, filming themselves crying over the ending, and debating whether Daisy and Billy should’ve ended up together.

When the TV by Amazon Prime Video adaptation was announced—with Riley Keough—who, by the way, is actual rock royalty as Elvis Presley’s granddaughter!—as Daisy and Sam Claflin as Billy—fans went wild. It became one of the most anticipated adaptations in recent memory, and once it hit screens, it didn’t disappoint. The show brought the band to life in a way that felt so real, especially with a full-fledged Aurora album being recorded for the series, giving fans the chance to actually hear the songs they’d only imagined while reading.

Pros and Cons of Daisy Jones & The Six

Like any great book, Daisy Jones & The Six has its high notes and maybe a few chords that don’t quite match the book’s melody. Here’s a breakdown of what really works and what might have readers feeling a little off-beat.

Pros:

Relatable Characters

Whether you love them or hate them, the characters in Daisy Jones & The Six are wild, flawed, and deeply human. Daisy’s free spirit and self-destruction, Billy’s constant battle between family and fame, Karen’s fierce independence—they all have layers. Even if you don’t agree with their choices, you understand them. And that’s the beauty of Taylor Jenkins Reid’s writing.

Strong Female Characters

The book showcases strong, complex women like Daisy, Karen Sirko, Camila (played by Camila Morrone), and Simone Jackson (Nabiyah Be)—each bringing their own power and voice to the story. Whether it’s Camila’s quiet strength or Daisy’s rebellious wildness, the female characters truly shine and add depth to what could’ve been just another rock band story.

Unique Storytelling Format

The oral history style is probably the book’s biggest strength. It makes the story feel like a documentary, with each character offering their own—sometimes conflicting—version of events. It’s fresh, engaging, and keeps you flipping pages just to see who says what next. Plus, the unreliable narrator element makes it all the more intriguing—you never quite know who’s telling the whole truth.

Nostalgic '70s Vibes

If you’re into classic rock, vintage fashion, and the golden era of “sex, drugs, and rock ‘n’ roll,” this book nails that atmosphere. The descriptions of recording sessions, sold-out concerts, and backstage drama make you feel like you’re right there in the thick of it. It’s easy to get lost in the world of this fictional band, which honestly feels way too real at times.

Emotional Depth

The book isn’t just about music—it dives deep into themes of addiction, identity, love, and the destructive nature of fame. It’s not all glitz and glam; there are real stakes here, and you’ll feel every one of them. It’s the kind of book that makes you think about real connections, what we sacrifice for our passions, and the way our choices shape who we become.

Cons:

Limited Access to Inner Thoughts

The oral history format is fun and unique, but it also keeps us at arm’s length from the characters. Since we’re only getting their interview responses, it can sometimes feel like we’re missing out on the deeper, rawer emotions that come with traditional narration. You don’t always get to sit in a character’s head and feel everything they’re feeling at that moment.

Not for Everyone’s Taste

Some readers may find the documentary style hard to get into. The constant shifts between narrators can be jarring if you’re used to a more linear, straightforward storytelling style. If you’re not into this kind of format, the book might not be a smooth ride from start to finish.

Overall, the pros definitely outweigh the cons, but it’s worth knowing what you’re getting into. If you love character-driven stories with a splash of nostalgia and some juicy tension, you’ll likely be all-in. But if you prefer a more traditional narrative style or expect a deeper focus on the music itself, this book might leave you wanting a bit more.

Conclusion

Daisy Jones and The Six is more than just a book—reading feels like being front row at a concert where the music is raging, the emotions are wild, and the drama is off the charts. Whether you’re living for Daisy’s untamed spirit, rooting for Billy’s redemption, or just soaking up the 1970s rock and roll vibes, this novel delivers an unforgettable experience. It’s chaotic, it’s heartbreaking, and it’s full of moments that will make you wish The Six were a real band.

So, if you’re in the mood for a story that feels like a backstage pass to both the glamour and the grit of the rock scene, this one deserves to be on your must-read list.

For more Daisy Jones and The Six content, join our world, and for more bookish deep dives and posts like this one, join our crewfiction and subscribe to our Tea & Cakes Newsletter!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is Daisy Jones & The Six about?

The novel follows the rise and fall of a fictional 1970s rock band, Daisy Jones & The Six. It's written in an oral history style, where the story unfolds through interviews with band members, crew, and others involved. At the heart of the story is the complicated relationship between lead singer Daisy Jones and the band’s frontman, Billy Dunne, as well as their creative and personal struggles during the making of their hit album Aurora.

Is Daisy Jones & The Six based on a true story?

No, the book is entirely fictional, though it was inspired by the real-life drama of bands from the 1970s, particularly Fleetwood Mac. The emotional intensity, love triangles, and creative conflicts within the band mirror the kind of tension that bands like Fleetwood Mac experienced during the making of albums like Rumours.

Is the music in Daisy Jones & The Six real?

No, the music in Daisy Jones & The Six is not real. While the book includes descriptions of the band’s songs and even provides full lyrics for some, these songs were created by the author. For the Amazon Prime TV adaptation, however, real music inspired by the book was written and recorded, bringing the fictional songs to life. Blake Mills, the well-known songwriter and producer, took the lead in creating the songs, and he worked with artists like Phoebe Bridgers, Marcus Mumford, Jackson Browne, and Taylor Goldsmith from Dawes to capture the '70s rock sound that defines the story.

Nina Siscou
Article written by:

Nina Siscou

First and foremost, Nina is a reader; she devours literature with gusto, from classic novels to contemporary poetry to graphic novels and everything in between. She believes that within each story, there's a universe waiting to be explored, and loves exploring with company. She's often found sharing her perspective on characters, plot twists, and literary themes with friends. When her friends get tired of listening to her ranting, she writes blog posts sharing her explorations with the other bookworms of the internet. In recent years she has developed an inexplicable addiction to matcha lattes, but has asked us not to talk about that.